* * The social contract

This essay of mine was published recently in the Roanoke Times. It has gotten much positive feedback and an invitation from Professor Sam Riley to speak to a class at VT in writing.
The social contract
This essay is about Pedro and Elizabeth.
Pedro is Pedro Loza, who lives in La Paz, Bolivia. Bolivia is the poorest and least developed country in South America. Like me, Pedro is a member of Rotary International. Earlier this year, Pedro was a team leader for a Rotary program called Group Study Exchange, as was I. Pedro brought a team of four young professionals from Bolivia to visit our district in the United States for five weeks starting in February. During the first week, he was a guest at my home. At the conclusion of their stay here, I led a similar team to his country.
Elizabeth is Elizabeth Warren, a candidate for the United States Senate from Massachusetts. Warren was one of the primary whistleblowers in the financial debacle of 2008 which led to our current, protracted recession. She has long advocated for consumer financial protection laws.
When Pedro had been in our country a few days, I asked what surprised him. He replied, “None of your houses have perimeter walls.” He went on to explain that everyone in his country who has any wealth protects their homes from thieves by surrounding them with walls. I was able to see this firsthand when I arrived. True to his description, every host home in six cities was either within a guarded, walled, gated community or had its own perimeter wall. These walls were typically 8 to 10 feet high and were often topped with barbed wire, razor wire, or embedded shards of broken glass. I found them oppressive.
In recent weeks, Elizabeth has become additionally famous for a viral video on the Internet in which she describes her views on what she calls our social contract. In it, she acknowledges the ingenuity and efforts of entrepreneurs and business leaders and the imperative of allowing them to keep much of their hard-earned income. However, she also admonishes that their success and freedom to do business is largely the result of the expenditures of everyone else. “There is nobody in this country who got rich on his own.” Entrepreneurs move their goods on the roads, are protected by police and firefighters, and hire workers educated from monies provided “by the rest of us.” We have many social systems that work in this nation for all of us; somebody has to pay for them.
Her articulation of the frustration of what we are now calling the 99% of us who do not pull the purse strings on our nation's economy is anathema to conservatives who consider every tax a bad tax and are actively striving to starve to elimination most publicly funded functions. What I found in Bolivia is the embodiment of an economy that fulfils that goal. Down there, it is every man for himself.
In Bolivia, public schools are dreadful, dreary, poorly equipped places where students are accepted on a lottery system and not everyone gets to go, especially any children with special needs. Children who come from households of means universally attend private schools.
In Bolivia, each person must provide their own theft protection because police departments are not funded well enough to protect the populace. Thus, the perimeter walls. We visited a factory that had an elaborate, electronic surveillance system to protect the owners from theft, both from outside and from within, but didn’t protect their workers from dangerous equipment, excessive noise, or particulate-laden air.
In Bolivia, packs of dogs roam the streets of every community, large and small. They do what unrestrained dogs do: fornicate, procreate, defecate, and create messes of every pile of garbage left outside. There is apparently no animal control.
Speaking of garbage, in Bolivia there appeared to be no landfills, as every roadside is filled with trash. Omnipresent are uncountable quantities of large Coca-Cola plastic bottle empties. I saw a car pull to the side of the road where the driver opened his trunk and threw plastic bags filled with garbage into the ditch.
In Bolivia, as far as I know, there are no public libraries.
Bolivia has nothing resembling our interstate highway system and only a few miles of four-lane highways.
Don't get me wrong, my experience in Bolivia was largely positive and I met many wonderful people. But what I found in terms of social systems is illustrative of the type of society conservatives seem to hope we will one day achieve.
Someone might argue that a society in which each person is responsible for taking care of his or her own needs, paying individually for roads, police protection, schools, trash pickup, and everything else, is more just and therefore more equitable. For me, though, it is simply not the type of place that I would want to live.